When it comes to long-lasting manicures, Shellac and gel nails are two of the most popular options. Both offer durability, shine, and chip resistance, but they have key differences that affect application, wear time, and removal.
If you’re unsure whether to choose Shellac or gel, this guide will break down the differences, pros and cons, and which one is best for your nail type and lifestyle.
What Is Shellac?
Shellac is a hybrid polish developed by CND (Creative Nail Design) that combines regular nail polish with gel properties. It provides a glossy finish and longer wear than traditional nail polish but is thinner than full gel manicures.
Key Features of Shellac:
✔ A mix of regular polish and gel
✔ Cured under a UV or LED lamp
✔ Lasts 10-14 days
✔ Easier to remove than gel
✔ Available in fewer colors compared to gel
Best for:
- Those who want a natural-looking, lightweight manicure
- People who prefer faster removal with minimal nail damage
- Anyone who changes their nail color often
What Are Gel Nails?
Gel nails are 100% gel-based and provide a stronger, more durable finish than Shellac. The gel is applied in layers and cured under a UV or LED lamp, creating a thicker and more flexible coating.
Key Features of Gel Nails:
✔ Made of pure gel formula
✔ Cured under UV or LED light
✔ Lasts 2-3 weeks or longer
✔ More resistant to chipping than Shellac
✔ Available in a wider range of colors and brands
Best for:
- Those who need a longer-lasting manicure
- People with weaker or brittle nails who need extra strength
- Anyone who wants nail extensions (since gel can be sculpted)
Shellac vs. Gel: Key Differences
| Feature | Shellac | Gel |
|---|---|---|
| Formula | Hybrid of polish + gel | 100% gel |
| Thickness | Thin and lightweight | Thicker and more protective |
| Wear Time | 10-14 days | 2-3 weeks or more |
| Curing Method | UV or LED lamp | UV or LED lamp |
| Shine | Glossy, but less than gel | Ultra-glossy and stays shiny |
| Chip Resistance | Moderate | High |
| Removal Process | Soaks off easily | Requires more soaking & buffing |
| Best for | Natural look, easy removal | Durability, strength, long wear |
Pros and Cons of Shellac and Gel
Shellac Pros:
✅ Faster application time
✅ Easier to remove than gel
✅ Less damage to natural nails
✅ Looks more natural and lightweight
Shellac Cons:
❌ Less durable than gel
❌ Limited color selection compared to gel brands
❌ Cannot be used for nail extensions
Gel Pros:
✅ Stronger and more durable than Shellac
✅ More color options available
✅ Can be used for sculpting nail extensions
✅ High-shine finish that lasts longer
Gel Cons:
❌ Harder to remove, requires more buffing
❌ May cause more nail damage over time
❌ Takes longer to apply compared to Shellac
Application Process: What to Expect
Both Shellac and gel nails follow a similar application process but with slight differences:
Shellac Application:
- Nail preparation – Nails are cleaned, shaped, and lightly buffed.
- Base coat application – A thin base coat is applied and cured under a UV/LED lamp.
- Color coats – Two layers of Shellac polish are applied, each cured under the lamp.
- Top coat application – A glossy top coat is applied and cured.
- Final step – The nails are wiped with alcohol to remove any tacky residue.
⏳ Total time: 30-45 minutes
Gel Application:
- Nail preparation – Nails are cleaned, shaped, and buffed.
- Base coat application – A layer of gel base coat is applied and cured under UV/LED light.
- Gel layers – Multiple layers of gel polish are applied, each cured under the lamp.
- Top coat application – A gel top coat is applied and cured for extra durability.
- Final step – Sticky residue is removed with alcohol.
⏳ Total time: 45-60 minutes
Removal Process: Shellac vs. Gel
Shellac removal is easier and less damaging to nails than gel removal.
How to Remove Shellac:
- Soak a cotton pad in acetone and place it on the nail.
- Wrap each finger with foil.
- Wait 10-15 minutes, then gently push off the polish.
How to Remove Gel:
- Buff the shiny top layer off.
- Soak nails in acetone for 15-20 minutes.
- Gently scrape off the gel with an orange stick.
- Buff nails lightly and apply cuticle oil to rehydrate.
💡 Tip: Always have gel removed by a professional to prevent nail thinning and damage.
Which One Is Better for You?
Choose Shellac if:
✔ You want a natural-looking manicure
✔ You change nail colors frequently
✔ You prefer faster and easier removal
Choose Gel if:
✔ You need a long-lasting, chip-resistant manicure
✔ You have weak or brittle nails that need extra protection
✔ You want nail extensions or sculpted nails
FAQs: Shellac vs. Gel
1. Does Shellac or Gel Last Longer?
Gel nails last longer (2-3 weeks) compared to Shellac (10-14 days).
2. Which One Is Healthier for Nails?
Shellac is gentler because it’s easier to remove without excessive buffing.
3. Can I Remove Gel or Shellac at Home?
Yes, but professional removal is recommended for gel to avoid nail damage.
4. Does Shellac or Gel Damage Natural Nails?
Both can weaken nails if not removed properly, but gel can cause more thinning over time.
5. Can I Apply Shellac or Gel on Natural Nails?
Yes! Both Shellac and gel can be applied directly to natural nails without extensions.
Both Shellac and gel manicures offer long-lasting color and shine, but the right choice depends on your lifestyle and nail needs.
✔ Go for Shellac if you want a lightweight, easy-to-remove option.
✔ Choose gel if you need durability and long wear.
No matter which one you pick, proper application and removal are key to keeping your nails healthy and strong.